Not too pigmented, not too glossy, the YSL Beauty Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick is the Goldilocks of tinted lip products—and it’s quickly become my new go-to for everyday wear.

It’s super easy to apply, thanks to its extra-smooth glide, and even easier (and comfortable!) to wear with its jelly texture (made with hydrating hyaluronic acid). I like that it’s shiny without being sticky and offers enough pigment to leave a subtle tint.

Right now, I’m loving Flashing Rosé, which is sheer rosy pink, but you really can’t go wrong with any of the shades—even the clear Healthy Glow Plumper, which gives lips a soft boost of moisture. (In the April Allure Beauty Box, subscribers chose between these four gorgeous shades: Healthy Glow Plumper, Watermelon High, Nude Lavalliere, Flashing Rosé.)

On days when I go into the office, I like to layer Flashing Rosé over a slightly deeper rosy mauve-hued lip liner, which gives my overall lip look just a tad bit more definition and a touch more pigment. Like I said, it’s my new everyday lip.

YSL Beauty’s Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick is in the April Allure Beauty Box.