One of my first makeup memories is of watching my mom apply eyeliner. It was a part of her everyday look. She would sharpen the tip, oftentimes down to the nub, and glide the black pencil across her waterlines—from the inner corner, out. I was always so impressed by the lined, but never smudged, final result.

Decades later, she still wears liner. But who doesn’t? A classic black eyeliner pencil is a makeup bag staple, and the Ofra Eyeliner Pencil in Black is one you’ll keep coming back to for its super-sharp tip, smooth glide, and water-resistant formula. It’s so versatile and can be used to create a number of looks: a feline flick, waterline depth, or a sultry smoky eye when smudged out. The options are endless!

Ofra Eyeliner Pencil in Black is a part of our Allure Beauty Box product lineup for October. Subscribe to Allure Beauty Box and get editor-approved picks in makeup, skincare, hair care, and fragrance delivered right to your door every month.