Aside from my trusty tubing mascara, I rarely wear eye makeup. (Brow products don’t count in this generalization.) But when I do, it’s usually some variation of a sparkly shadow for a special occasion.

On these nights (well, at the end of them), I skip my usual double-cleanse routine and instead reach for something stronger: a bi-phase eye makeup remover. It cuts through the glitter faster than my cleansing balm ever could.

I really like Sephora Collection Express Waterproof Makeup Remover, which is formulated with cornflower extract and castor oil soothe and moisturize lids and lashes, while silky silicones help obliterate said stubborn shadow (and sweatproof mascara and waterproof liquid liner).

To use, I give it a quick shake, then sprinkle a few drops onto a cotton round (or reusable cloth if I’m at home and not traveling) before gently pressing into (closed) eyelids. From there, I lightly move and massage the pads until all of the makeup has been transferred. Sometimes this process requires a couple of rinse-and-repeat steps, but for the most part, most of the makeup comes off in the first round—without causing any sort of irritation, which is a feat for my sensitive eyes!

You can find the Sephora Collection Express Waterproof Makeup Remover, along with other editor-loved products, in the February Allure Beauty Box.