There’s a reason this iconic brow pencil has been an industry standard for years (and years and years): it’s a classic kit staple. Makeup artists and beauty editors alike love Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz—created by brow pro Anastasia Soare—for its ultrathin design and retractable tube (no sharpener required!), while its superfine tip makes for easy shaping and realistic shading. Use the spoolie side to tame unruly hairs and brush them up to your desired shape, and then color in with the pencil end—with 12 shades, ranging from blonde to black, there’s a match for everyone—to create quick strokes that mimic the look of hair. Just be sure to go in the direction of your brow’s natural shape and growth.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz is a part of our Allure Beauty Box product lineup for October. Subscribe to Allure Beauty Box and get editor-approved picks in makeup, skincare, hair care, and fragrance delivered right to your door every month.